Which creative agency should a DTC brand use for Meta ads?
Start with two questions: do you already have a media buyer, and how much do you spend on Meta a month? If you have a buyer and need more ads, look at creative-only shops like SelfMade ($6K to $20K a month, published) or Y'all's creative-only tier (from $10K a month). If you want one team for creative and buying, look at Common Thread Collective ($100K+ a month on Meta), Flighted ($25K+), BNGR or Loud Lion ($20K+). Under $30K a month, check minimums first: SelfMade starts at $30K and Loud Lion at $20K, while Y'all and inBeat list no minimum.
How do the agencies compare?
From each agency's own website, as of November 16, 2026. "Not published" means we couldn't find a number on their site. Ask them directly.
| Agency | What they do | Pricing | Built for | Creative volume |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SelfMade | Creative only (media buying add-on) | $6,000 to $20,000 a month, published | $30K to $200K a month on Meta | 8 to 45 new concepts a week |
| Y'all | Creative only, or full service | Creative from $10K a month; full service from $17.5K a month | No minimum stated | Not stated as a standard |
| Common Thread Collective | Creative plus media buying | Not published | $100K+ a month on Meta | UGC packages of 20, 40 or 80 ads |
| Sweat Pants Agency | Full service; creative can be bought alone | Not published | Brands with $3M to $100M+ revenue | "Calibrated to what is efficient for your account" |
| Flighted | Creative plus media buying | Not published | $25K+ a month | 1,000+ creatives a month across all clients |
| Pilothouse | Creative plus media buying | Retainer plus performance incentives | Not stated | Not stated |
| BNGR | Creative plus Meta-first media buying | Not published | About $30K to $800K+ a month on paid social | 25+ concepts a month |
| inBeat | Creative, creators and paid media | Not published | No minimum stated | Not stated as a standard |
| Loud Lion | Creative plus media buying | Scoped to spend, "four-to-five-figure-per-month range" | $20K+ a month on Meta | 50 to 200+ ads a month |
When does a creative-only agency make sense?
When someone already runs your ads well, in-house or at an agency, and the bottleneck is new creative. A creative-only team ships ads into your account and leaves budgets and campaign setup to your buyer. You also keep the option to change buyers without changing your creative team.
When does creative plus media buying make sense?
When nobody owns the Meta account day to day, or when you want one team accountable for both the ads and the results. Expect a higher monthly fee, and at some agencies a fee that grows with spend. Y'all, for example, moves full-service clients to a percentage of spend starting at 10% once they spend $175K a month.
What should you ask any agency before signing?
Volume for your account
How many new concepts a month for a brand at your spend, not across all clients.
What counts as a new ad
Is a hook version or a resize counted as a new ad?
How they pick what to make
Do they start from your account's data and customer research, or from a template?
Who owns the files
Do you keep the raw files and the rights when you leave?
Commitment
Month-to-month, or a minimum term?
Sources
See where your brand sits.
Run the free audit. Free, about 60 seconds.